Arb Files
Arb Files
@ArbFiles

The creative didn't die. The frequency did.

The setup. Native widget campaign, nutra offer, broad US desktop. One creative carried it for 11 days. Figures are illustrative.

The move. When ROI slid from 1.4 to 0.9 I assumed creative fatigue and swapped in six fresh angles. They all underperformed the "tired" one.

The numbers. Original creative lifetime: $14,000 spend, 1.28 blended ROI. The replacements burned $1,900 at 0.71 before I pulled them. The original at the SAME frequency cap was still doing 1.1 — I'd been letting frequency climb to 7+ on a finite audience.

The lesson. On a capped traffic source, falling ROI isn't always the ad wearing out. It's the audience saturating. Same creative, same people, fifth time — of course response drops. I was treating a reach problem like a creative problem.

What I'd do differently. Separate the two signals. If a new creative to the same audience also tanks, it's saturation, not fatigue — widen geo or add placements, don't churn creatives. I now log frequency alongside ROI on every line so I can tell which wall I actually hit.
This post was published in the Telegram channel Arb Files (@ArbFiles). All its posts are on the channel page.
Open on Telegram

Latest posts in “Media buying”

All channels in this category →

реклама в сети

Готовы запустить рекламу через сеть public.tg?

Новый оффер, продукт, GEO, кейс, событие или партнёрский запуск — соберём маршрут под задачу и отдадим медиаплан.

Telegram для медиаплана: @AFFtop_connect. Быстрый тест: $20 за канал, $1000 за пакет по сети.