The paranoia-driven advice: new domain every campaign so nothing gets flagged together. I did it religiously and shot myself in three different feet.
The setup
Running 6 offers, 6 fresh domains, each spun up days before launch.
The move
When results were inconsistent, I compared fresh-domain campaigns against ones on an aged, warmed domain.
The numbers
Fresh domains: higher bot-block rates, no trust signals, and one got sandboxed by the ad network on day 2 (lost $400 in disapproved spend). The aged domain ran clean and converted 18% better on identical creative — trust and consistent pixel history compounded. Fresh-per-campaign cost me roughly $1,500 in flagged spend and lost trust equity over a quarter.
The lesson
Fresh domains have zero trust, zero history, and higher scrutiny. Unless you're running something that genuinely burns domains, you're throwing away accumulated reputation for imagined safety.
What I'd do differently
Age and warm a small stable of domains, reuse the clean ones. Fresh-per-campaign is cargo-cult caution for most legit verticals. Numbers illustrative; the trust penalty is real.
Arb Files
@ArbFiles
"Always use a fresh domain per campaign" — the myth that wrecked my deliverability and tracking
This post was published in the Telegram channel Arb Files (@ArbFiles). All its posts are on the channel page.
Open on Telegram