Affiliate managers wave the big payout in your face and the advice echoes it: higher payout, more room. I picked on payout alone and got punished by the funnel.
The setup
Two offers, same vertical. Offer A: $80 payout. Offer B: $35 payout. I took A, obviously.
The move
After A underperformed I ran both side by side and looked at conversion rate AND hold rate (scrubbed/reversed leads), not just the headline.
The numbers
Offer A ($80): 0.9% conversion, 30% of leads scrubbed = effective $50 per accepted lead, hard to convert. Offer B ($35): 3.1% conversion, 5% scrub = far easier, and earnings per click landed at $0.41 vs A's $0.28. The "smaller" offer made 46% more per click.
The lesson
Payout is one term in the equation. Conversion rate and scrub rate decide what you actually keep. A high payout on a leaky offer is a trap.
What I'd do differently
I rank offers by realistic earnings per click after scrub, never by sticker payout. Big numbers are bait. Figures illustrative; the EPC inversion is constant.
Arb Files
@ArbFiles
"Pick the highest-payout offer" — I chased $80 payouts straight into a loss
This post was published in the Telegram channel Arb Files (@ArbFiles). All its posts are on the channel page.
Open on Telegram