No creative change, no offer change, no targeting change. The auction moved under me.
The setup
— Stable evergreen campaign, $16 payout, ~$1,500/day, ROI 38% for a month.
— Then it slid to 18% over ten days for no reason I could see in my account.
The move
I almost rebuilt everything. First I checked CPMs against my own historical baseline.
The numbers (illustrative)
— Average CPM rose 31% in those ten days, a big advertiser had entered my niche/GEO and bid up the auction.
— My conversion rate was flat. My cost side simply inflated.
— Same machine, thinner margin, entirely external.
The lesson
Margin compression often comes from outside your account. When ROI slides with no internal change, suspect the auction before you suspect your funnel. You can A/B test creatives forever and never beat a bidding war you didn't know you were in.
What I'd do differently
Track CPM as a first-class metric, not an afterthought. Diversify across 2-3 traffic sources so one source's CPM spike can't sink the whole operation. Concentration feels efficient right up until the auction turns.
Arb Files
@ArbFiles
My ROI dropped 20 points and I hadn't touched a thing
This post was published in the Telegram channel Arb Files (@ArbFiles). All its posts are on the channel page.
Open on Telegram