The daily ROI looked fine. The hourly breakdown was hiding a leak.
The setup
— Lead-gen offer, $9 payout, search-feed traffic, ~$1,100/day, ROI 24%.
— I'd never once looked at the hour-of-day report.
The move
Pulled 30 days of data, bucketed conversions by hour. The overnight window was a graveyard.
The numbers (illustrative)
— 1am-6am: ~40% of spend, conversion rate 1.0%, ROI -20%.
— 9am-9pm: conversion rate 2.3%, ROI +51%.
— The good daytime hours were quietly subsidizing a money-losing night shift.
The lesson
A blended ROI number can hide two completely different campaigns inside one. Averages comfort you while a segment bleeds. The leak was invisible at the daily level and obvious at the hourly one.
What I'd do differently
Add dayparting from launch on any offer where intent is time-sensitive (loans, calls, B2B). I cut the overnight window and the same campaign jumped from 24% to 44% ROI without a single new creative. Pure waste removal.
Arb Files
@ArbFiles
40% of my spend ran between 1am and 6am and converted at half the rate
This post was published in the Telegram channel Arb Files (@ArbFiles). All its posts are on the channel page.
Open on Telegram