Arb Files
Arb Files
@ArbFiles

Manual CPC vs target-CPA bidding: when handing the algo the wheel cost me margin

The setup: Scaling a stable Facebook campaign, $200/day, +35% ROI on manual lowest-cost bidding. The temptation: switch to cost-cap to protect margin while scaling.

The move: Cloned the campaign, set cost cap at our break-even CPA, scaled both to $400/day over a week.

The numbers (illustrative): Manual campaign scaled to $400/day, ROI compressed to +22% (normal at scale). Cost-cap campaign refused to spend — delivered only $140/day because the cap was too tight, then when we loosened it, it overshot and hit +4% ROI as the algo chased volume.

The lesson: Bid caps protect you from the downside and rob you of the upside. The algo optimizes to your cap, not your profit. On a campaign that's already winning, manual scaling preserves more margin than handing control to a CPA target.

What I'd do differently: Cost caps belong on NEW campaigns where you're scared of overspend, not on proven winners. I bolted a safety belt onto a car that was already driving fine and slowed it down. Use caps to learn, manual to milk.
This post was published in the Telegram channel Arb Files (@ArbFiles). All its posts are on the channel page.
Open on Telegram

Latest posts in “Media buying”

All channels in this category →

реклама в сети

Готовы запустить рекламу через сеть public.tg?

Новый оффер, продукт, GEO, кейс, событие или партнёрский запуск — соберём маршрут под задачу и отдадим медиаплан.

Telegram для медиаплана: @AFFtop_connect. Быстрый тест: $20 за канал, $1000 за пакет по сети.