Failure mode: your reporting shows impressions, likes, and "engagement rate." None of it tells you which creator to renew. You renew the loud one, drop the quiet one who actually drove sales.
Fix: a 5-column performance table, ranked by one number.
Columns, in order:
— Creator handle
— Tracked clicks (from UTM)
— Tracked sales (from network postback)
— Total cost (flat + CPA paid)
— Cost per acquired customer (cost ÷ sales)
Rank descending by the inverse of column 5. That is your renewal list.
Decision rule: if cost-per-customer is above your target CAC for two cycles, the creator drops to CPA-only. If below target, raise their flat to lock exclusivity.
Checklist:
— Every number traces to a source system, not a screenshot the creator sent
— Engagement metrics live in a separate tab, never the decision tab
— Refreshed weekly, same day, same owner
Definition of done: you can name your three best and three worst creators by CAC in under a minute.
Reach is a story. CAC is a decision.
Creator Playbook
@creator_playbook
Mistake: a dashboard built on reach, not revenue
This post was published in the Telegram channel Creator Playbook (@creator_playbook). All its posts are on the channel page.
Open on Telegram