'Q: A product is permanently discontinued. Delete it, 404 it, or leave it up?'
Short answer: 301 redirect it to the closest replacement or its parent category — never let it 404 if it had backlinks or rankings.
The longer version: it depends on three factors, so here they are. (1) Temporarily out of stock → keep the page live, status 200, add a 'notify me' or 'similar items' block. Removing it loses rankings you'll want back next week. (2) Permanently gone with a near-identical successor → 301 to the successor. (3) Permanently gone with no replacement → 301 to the parent category, or 410 if it was thin and trafficless.
The trap beginners hit: bulk-404ing discontinued SKUs every season. You torch accumulated link equity and create soft-404 noise.
— Rule of thumb: temporary = keep, permanent = redirect, junk = 410.
Got an e-com SEO question? Drop it.
Cart & Crawl
@CartAndCrawl
What do I do with out-of-stock product pages?
This post was published in the Telegram channel Cart & Crawl (@CartAndCrawl). All its posts are on the channel page.
Open on Telegram