A: Often the wrong default, and it quietly breaks user counts. Properties are walls, not folders.
— GA4 can't dedupe a user across separate properties, so a person visiting all 3 sites counts as 3 users — your totals inflate.
— Better: one property, multiple data streams (Admin → Data Streams → Add stream), unified under cross-domain.
— Use separate properties only when sites have different owners, billing, or legal data boundaries.
UA-era 'one property per site' habits don't fit GA4's streams model.
TL;DR: One property + multiple streams beats property-per-site for cross-site users. Split only for true separation.
Got a GA4 question? Drop it 👇
GA4 Triage
@GA4Triage
Q: Best practice I read: one GA4 property per website. Should I split my 3 sites into 3 properties?
This post was published in the Telegram channel GA4 Triage (@GA4Triage). All its posts are on the channel page.
Open on Telegram