The button under URL Inspection is a crawl request, not an index command. It bumps the URL into a priority crawl queue. Google still re-evaluates quality, canonical, and duplicate signals before indexing — and routinely declines.
What it's good for:
— Speeding up a crawl after fixing a real issue (you changed the noindex, you added content)
— A single new page you want seen this week
Pros:
— Free, instant submit, no API setup
— Honest status feedback ("Indexing requested")
Cons:
— ~10 URL/day soft cap, daily quota shared across the property
— Zero guarantee; thin or duplicate pages stay out
— Useless at scale (don't try 500 URLs)
Best for: nudging a handful of genuinely improved pages. NOT for sites trying to bulk-index thin content — that's a quality problem the button can't fix.
Verdict: 3/5. A crawl accelerator, not an index switch.
Index or Bust
@IndexOrBust
Myth: "Request Indexing" in GSC forces Google to index a page
This post was published in the Telegram channel Index or Bust (@IndexOrBust). All its posts are on the channel page.
Open on Telegram