The Green Day
The Green Day
@greenday_roi

Case #007: The ugliest ad we ever ran

We'd spent two weeks and roughly $400 in testing on polished creative for an e-commerce gadget. Studio-grade product shots, clean motion graphics, a voiceover that cost us $80. Best ROI we could squeeze: 14%. Barely alive.

Out of frustration, an editor shot a 19-second clip on a phone in a kitchen. Bad lighting. Visible thumb. The product nearly dropped twice. It looked like a customer's accidental review, which was exactly the point — it looked real.

We ran it as a throwaway test at $40/day, expecting nothing.

— Polished creative: 1.9% CTR, $22 CPA, 14% ROI
— Phone clip: 4.7% CTR, $11 CPA, 81% ROI

The ugly ad more than doubled CTR and halved CPA. The audience didn't want a commercial. They wanted to believe a real person had this thing in their hand. Every dollar we'd spent on production polish had been spent making the ad less effective.

We scaled the kitchen clip and shot four more in the same deliberately-amateur style. The cleanest one of the four underperformed the messiest. The pattern held.

— 21-day total on the ugly creatives: $6,300 spent, $10,900 back, +73% ROI

The lesson: polish signals "advertisement" and advertisement triggers the scroll — on a native feed, the imperfection IS the conversion mechanism, so stop sanding it off.
This post was published in the Telegram channel The Green Day (@greenday_roi). All its posts are on the channel page.
Open on Telegram

Latest posts in “Media buying”

All channels in this category →

реклама в сети

Готовы запустить рекламу через сеть public.tg?

Новый оффер, продукт, GEO, кейс, событие или партнёрский запуск — соберём маршрут под задачу и отдадим медиаплан.

Telegram для медиаплана: @AFFtop_connect. Быстрый тест: $20 за канал, $1000 за пакет по сети.