Popular advice: aim for 30 to 40 percent, anything less means you're doing it wrong. Myth.
Those numbers come from warm or referral outreach dressed up as cold. Genuinely cold, well-targeted creator DMs land in the high single digits to low teens — and that's a healthy campaign. Chasing 40 percent will push you toward smaller, easier lists that can't fill a real pipeline.
It's not a low reply rate that's the problem, it's measuring against a fake benchmark. Track replies-per-100 and replies-that-close separately.
Cold DM Confidential
@ColdDMConfidential
"What reply rate should I expect as a beginner?"
This post was published in the Telegram channel Cold DM Confidential (@ColdDMConfidential). All its posts are on the channel page.
Open on Telegram