Q: Two antifraud tools score the same click totally differently. Who's right?
A: Both, in their own frame. There's no universal fraud score — each vendor builds its own model on its own data, weighting signals differently. The disagreement is the system working as designed, not a bug.
Where they diverge:
— Data scope: a vendor that sees billions of clicks across thousands of advertisers has IP and device reputation that a smaller tool simply doesn't.
— Risk appetite: some models optimize to never miss fraud and over-flag; others optimize to never block a real user and under-flag.
— Signal emphasis: one leans on IP reputation, another on behavioral biometrics. Your traffic's weak spot decides which one flinches.
The practical implication: the score that matters is the one your advertiser uses, because that's what determines payout. Ask which provider sits in their stack, then optimize against that model's known sensitivities rather than chasing a perfect score everywhere.
Short version: scores are vendor opinions, not facts. Optimize for the tool in your advertiser's pipeline, not the friendliest one you can find.
Still stuck? Drop your case in the comments.
Clean Traffic Desk
@CleanTrafficDesk
Why does one tool say my traffic is fine and another flags it?
This post was published in the Telegram channel Clean Traffic Desk (@CleanTrafficDesk). All its posts are on the channel page.
Open on Telegram