Short answer: run a three-question test before you create a new URL — splintering into thin pages hurts authority more than consolidating helps it.
— Does this idea have its own search demand and intent? If no, it's a section, not a page
— Could you write 800+ genuinely useful words on it alone? If no, fold it in
— Would it compete with an existing page for the same query? If yes, merge instead
Pass all three and it earns its own page. Fail any and it becomes a section with an anchor link.
In practice: a fully-covered topic with fewer, stronger pages beats the same topic spread across many thin ones. Default to consolidation and only split when the demand clearly justifies a separate URL.
On the fence about a page? Describe it and send it in.
Authority Stack
@AuthorityStack
Q: How do I decide whether a new idea should be its own page or a section of an existing one?
This post was published in the Telegram channel Authority Stack (@AuthorityStack). All its posts are on the channel page.
Open on Telegram